“I love you, but I’m not In Love with you”

by

Holey House is supported by its readers.

When you make a purchase using a link on this page I may earn a commission.

Disclaimer: I am not a licensed therapist or mental health professional. I am a trauma survivor. If you need help, please seek the services of a licensed professional (see my Resources Page for suggestions). The contents of this website are for educational, informational, and entertainment purposes only. Information on this page might not be accurate or up-to-date. Accordingly, this page should not be used as a diagnosis of any medical illness, mental or physical. This page is also not a substitute for professional counseling, therapy, or any other type of medical advice.  Some topics discussed on this website could be upsetting. If you are triggered by this website’s content you should seek the services of a trained and licensed professional.

When Rejection in Romance Reawakens the Pain of Childhood Trauma

There are moments that bend us. And then there are moments that break us open in a way that only survivors of deep, complex trauma can understand.

To someone else, “I love you, but I’m not in love with you,” might sound like a gentle truth—an honest expression of emotional clarity in a relationship that’s lost its romantic spark. But to someone who’s lived through the soul-twisting distortion of incest or childhood sexual abuse, those words can land like an emotional grenade—quiet at first, but explosive underneath.

This post isn’t just about romantic heartbreak. It’s about the invisible wounds survivors carry. Wounds that don’t just bleed in relationships—but scream for acknowledgement, healing, and dignity.

I want to speak to the survivor who heard those words and spiraled. To the one who couldn’t stop crying, not because the relationship ended, but because the pain felt so familiar. To the one who suddenly felt 7 years old again. Unseen. Unwanted. Unchosen.

This Isn’t Just Rejection. It’s a Trauma Echo.

When someone you love tells you they’re not “in love” with you, it can sound like a quiet goodbye. But if you’re an incest survivor, it’s rarely heard that simply.

It may not just be your romantic partner’s voice you hear. It could be your father’s silence. Your uncle’s manipulation. Your mother’s willful ignorance. Your first memory of being used and then forgotten.

This moment becomes an echo chamber of every time you weren’t enough. Not good enough to protect. Not good enough to believe. Not good enough to keep.

You’re not just mourning the end of a relationship—you’re mourning the part of you that dared to hope this one would be different.

Core Wounds: The Hidden Narratives That Won’t Let Go

Survivors don’t arrive at love with clean slates. They come in carrying histories. Scripts. Internal narratives that sound like:

  • “If someone really sees me, they’ll leave.”
  • “I’m hard to love.”
  • “Love will always hurt.”

So when a partner says, “I’m not in love with you,” it doesn’t feel like a reflection of their capacity. It feels like confirmation of everything you fear about yourself.

This is how shame compounds. Not because of what was said—but because of what it awakens.

A survivor may not think:

“This just wasn’t a good fit.”

Instead, they may hear:

  • “I was a fool to think I was worthy.”
  • “I should’ve known better.”
  • “I’m still the broken one.”

The Flashback You Can’t Explain

You might not see it coming. You may feel fine at first—numb even. And then, suddenly, it’s like something inside you collapses. You can’t eat. You can’t sleep. You feel like you’re falling into something vast and familiar.

That’s not “overreacting.” That’s not “being too sensitive.” That’s called an emotional flashback.

Emotional flashbacks are trauma time-travel. You’re not just reacting to this partner—you’re reliving the rejection, abandonment, or betrayal from your earliest years.

Your body remembers what your mind can’t explain. And this moment becomes bigger than now. Because the wound is older than the relationship.

Confusing Trauma for Love: When Abuse Feels Familiar

If you were taught that love comes in the form of being taken from, touched without consent, or manipulated into silence, then your body associates love with pain. With confusion. With fear.

As adults, this often shows up as trauma-bonding.

So when a romantic relationship feels intense, a survivor might think:

“This must be love.”

But it might just be the nervous system recognizing what it knows—chaos, urgency, longing.

If a survivor interpreted their relationship as redemptive or healing, and the partner says “I’m not in love with you,” it can feel like the ground splits beneath them.

The pain isn’t just from the breakup. It’s from the loss of what they thought this relationship meant: A chance to rewrite their story.

Now, the narrative they wanted to change feels like it’s been re-engraved even deeper.

The Ache of Not Being Chosen

When you grow up being used instead of loved, survival can depend on how well you perform. How well you please. How much you adapt.

You learn to be good. To be what others want. To be worthy of being kept. Your whole worth becomes entangled in being chosen.

So when someone says, “I love you, but I’m not in love with you,” it doesn’t land as neutral honesty. It feels like being discarded. Forgotten. Like all your effort was for nothing.

It’s not just rejection. It’s a rupture in your identity.

Grieving the Dream, Not Just the Person

For many survivors, relationships represent more than companionship. They are attempts at healing. They are where we hope to experience the love we should have gotten as children.

So when it ends, the grief isn’t just about the person. It’s about the dream. The fantasy. The belief that “this time, it’ll be different.”

And when that dream dissolves, so does hope. Even if only for a little while.

You’re not just grieving them. You’re grieving the child inside you who thought she’d finally found home.

The Spiral Into Self-Doubt

When you don’t have a solid internal compass—because it was shattered by betrayal early on—it’s easy to believe that every failed relationship is your fault.

You may question:

  • “Was I too much?”
  • “Did I make this up in my head?”
  • “Was the intimacy real for them—or just for me?”
  • “Am I fundamentally unlovable?”

You may replay every conversation, every text, every moment you thought meant something—and twist it into evidence that you were wrong.

This is what trauma does. It doesn’t just break your heart—it shatters your ability to trust yourself.

Why It’s Not “Just a Breakup”

People may say:

  • “You’ll get over it.”
  • “It wasn’t meant to be.”
  • “At least they were honest.”

But those responses erase the survivor’s context.

This was not just about one person. It was about the entire structure of hope, healing, and longing they had built around that person.

When you grew up in chaos, any relationship you open your heart to is risky. Vulnerability is terrifying. So the loss of that relationship feels like failure, like shame, like humiliation.

But even more than that—it feels like reliving the heartbreak of being invisible. Again.

What Healing Can Look Like From This Place

If you’re here, reading this, broken open by love that didn’t last the way you hoped—let me say this with all the fire of someone who’s been there:

You are not too broken to be loved.

You were not wrong to hope. You were not foolish to believe in love. You are not unworthy because someone else couldn’t meet you where you are.

What you’re feeling right now is not proof that you’re defective. It’s proof that your soul still longs for connection. That despite everything—you are still capable of love.

And that is holy.

Reclaiming Your Power One Truth at a Time

Here are some truths to hold on to when the pain feels too big to bear:

  • The end of a relationship is not a measure of your value.
  • You are allowed to feel devastated without needing to justify it.
  • Your trauma responses are not character flaws—they’re survival adaptations.
  • You are still worthy of a love that is safe, steady, and reciprocal.
  • Someone’s inability to love you the way you deserve is not a reflection of your worth.

Let that last one land. Really land.

If You’re in the Middle of It…

Let yourself feel it. Don’t bypass the grief. Don’t minimize it. Don’t rush to be okay.

Cry. Write. Scream into your pillow. Talk to someone who won’t shrink from your truth. Find spaces where your pain is allowed to exist without needing to be fixed.

And when you’re ready—come back to yourself. The You who existed before this relationship. The You who still deserves tenderness. The You who has survived worse and still chose love.

You Are Not Alone

This moment may feel like the end—but it’s an invitation.

An invitation to give yourself the love you hoped someone else would. To rebuild not just your heart, but your sense of self. To tend to the child inside you who has always deserved more.

You are not unloved. You are not unwanted. You are not unworthy.

You are becoming.

And one day, when you’ve held your own heart long enough to hear it clearly, You’ll know this truth in your bones:

I am love. I do not have to be chosen to be enough. I am already whole.

In the ashes of false love, the real you rises.
And I promise you—you are worth rising for.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

"Trauma is personal. It does not disappear if it is not validated. It does not magically heal if you pretend it never happened. The only way to dissolve it is to put it in context with a broader story.

- Judith Lewis Herman -

Make a one-time donation

Your contribution is appreciated.

Donate

Make a monthly donation

Your contribution is appreciated.

Donate monthly

Make a yearly donation

Your contribution is appreciated.

Donate yearly

"Emotion is not opposed to reason.
Our emotions assign values to experiences and thus are the foundation of reason."

- Bessel A. van der Kolk -

The roots of resilience... Are to be found in the sense of being understood by and existing in the mind and heart of a loving, attuned, and self-possessed other.

- Diana Fosha -

Learn More about Trauma

Boundary Medicine

My boundaries are not negotiable—they are essential tools for safety, self-worth, and emotional healing.

Partner Traits That Can Retraumatize Incest Survivors

Certain emotional, sexual, and relational behaviors in romantic partners can retraumatize incest survivors by mirroring the dynamics of their original abuse.

An Ideal Partner for an Incest Survivor

The essential qualities of a romantic partner who supports healing from incest trauma—not by rescuing, but by offering consistent, respectful, and emotionally safe love. How true intimacy is built through presence, patience, and honoring the survivor’s pace and boundaries.

Healing the Distorted Beliefs Left by Incest Trauma

How incest survivors can begin healing the deeply rooted, distorted beliefs left by trauma by reconnecting with truth, self-worth, and embodied safety.

Distorted Core Beliefs About Love, Power, Sex, Trust, and Self-Worth After Incest

Incest deeply distorts a survivor’s core beliefs about love, power, sex, trust, and self-worth, shaping survival adaptations that feel like truths but keep them trapped in pain and shame. Healing begins by recognizing these lies and reclaiming truths rooted in safety, dignity, and empowerment.

The Deep Wounds of Father-Daughter Incest

Father-daughter incest shatters the very foundation of trust, love, and safety a child needs, leaving deep wounds that ripple into adult relationships. Yet, through compassionate understanding and healing, survivors can reclaim their worth and learn to build connections grounded in respect, safety, and authentic love.

Why Emotional Regulation feel Impossible for Incest Survivors

Emotional regulation is a profound struggle for incest survivors because their nervous systems were shaped by betrayal, chronic danger, and emotional invalidation during critical developmental years.

What an Incest Survivor Needs to Feel Safe, Connected, and Valued in a Relationship

Love after incest is sacred, not impossible—it requires safety, slowness, and the kind of steady presence that honors both the survivor’s pain and their power.

Unrequited Love When You’re a Survivor

Unrequited love can reopen old wounds for survivors of incest and childhood trauma, making the ache feel unbearable—but this heartbreak is not proof that you’re unlovable. You are worthy of a love that sees, honors, and chooses you freely.

Another Dirty Secret: The Immense Pain of Being Kept Hidden

Being kept a secret in a romantic relationship can reopen the deepest wounds of incest trauma, echoing the shame, powerlessness, and invisibility once endured in silence.